Enough is enough…
I haven’t gone off the handle in a little bit, so allow me to do that now as I recap a few things that went down in the CIS the past couple of days:
• The Brandon Bobcats lost to the Regina Cougars last Friday and apparently paid for that loss four days later. The Bobcats were dropped from No. 2 to No. 3 in the national rankings despite the fact that playoff series are considered one game, as it relates to the rankings … at least that was the belief of everybody I talked to before Tuesday’s perplexing turn of events. Brandon went on to win that series, but still took a hit in the rankings as if the loss in Game 1 was being counted. If it’s regular season, fine. If it’s playoffs, it’s supposed to be the series that counts, not individual results. No one has explained this further and I’m still hoping for that explanation and I’m praying it’s not something as simple as “the coaches screwed up.”
• While we’re talking about coaches, have to chime in and say I disagreed with the selection of Alberta’s Don Horwood as Canada West coach of the year. I know, I know … far be it for anyone to ever say anything against people in the close-knit Canadian university community, but I don’t get it. No one here is questioning Horwood’s history as a great coach, one of the finest this country has watched for decades. But explain to me what the incredible coaching job that was done in Edmonton this season. The Bears went 16-6 this season, a one-win improvement from last. They didn’t finish first in their division, they had the fourth best record in the conference and they got swept in the division finals (which, to be fair, has no bearing on these awards, which are decided upon a couple of weeks prior).
Is Horwood retiring after this season? Is there a plan afoot to give him one last honour so he goes out on top? Listen, I have no beef with that team. I think the Bears are pretty darn good and have every chance in the world of winning a berth into nationals. I just simply don’t understand what it was that was so remarkable about this season that said to the other coaches “Wow, Don has really done something special there this season.” I wouldn’t be shocked at all if Alberta wins on Friday night, but I also wouldn’t say that all adds up to Horwood being COY.
Meanwhile, Calgary’s Dan Vanhooren watched his team improve by eight wins over last season and win the Central Division. It would be shocking to not see the Dinos in Ottawa given the set-up that’s in front of them.
Brandon’s Mike Raimbault had it tough, too. He took over a veteran-laden team that went 20-2 last season and just missed out on winning a national title. Doesn’t sound bad? Well, consider how exceptional a 20-2 record is in this conference — arguably the toughest in the country. So even if you go back and do it again (and the Bobcats did), people can say “well, yeah but you had almost the same team as last year.” There was an expectation there. Raimbault merely lived up to it (so far). That’s not all that enticing to voters, apparently.
UBC’s Kevin Hanson has brought his T-Birds back into the final four, the first time he’s had to go on without all-Canadian Casey Archibald. The T-Birds returned a good chunk of last season’s team but not Archibald, the unequivocal “team on his back” guy for UBC.
I don’t know if you can make a real case for Hanson, but here’s what the Canada West press release had to say about Horwood:
“Long-time Alberta bench boss Don Horwood is the conference Coach of the Year, as selected by his fellow coaches. Horwood, in his 40th year overall of coaching basketball, took the team to a solid 16-6 record, good for second place in the Central Division, and his Bears now have a spot in the Final Four at Calgary this weekend, where the two semifinal winners on Friday earn a berth to Nationals. He has taken Alberta to three national titles in his career, two second-place finishes and one bronze medal, while racking up 566 overall victories, 300 conference wins and a 70-56 playoff record.”
If we’re talking about coach of the YEAR, then that paragraph should have stopped after the words “at Calgary.” There is only one sentence — conveniently bolded for your viewing pleasure — that actually relates to this season. The rest is filler and wholly unrelated to the voting of coach of the year. No one will argue his historical impact, but you should be able to debate the fact there were better options for this season’s top coach.
• The more I thought about it, the more I was fine with Alex Steele being named conference MVP. The fifth-year guard was huge for the Bears and was regularly the guy talked about by other coaches, a sure sign you’ve got some juice in the conference. The other fact, I thought, was that there were some great players this season yet no one jumped out at you far and away over everyone else. You can shoot down most other suggestions: Anyone on Brandon (too deep, too many important guys); Henry Bekkering (see again depth, plus he was apparently only thought worthy of a second-team all-star); Andrew Spagrud (team was too flawed and not successful enough); Chris Dyck (big to his team, but is he the most valuable of them all?). If I honestly were to pick a runner-up to Steele, I’d probably side with Dyck. You saw how his team struggled when he wasn’t playing and the genuine lift he gave the Birds when he was in there.
• We’ll apologize if there exists a Scrum curse because it has apparently claimed the Windsor Lancers. Two days after appearing on our podcast, Chris Oliver and his Lancers were stunned by the Western Mustangs in the OUA West semifinal Wednesday night at the St. Denis Centre. The Lancers could very well be cooked now, but will be able to put their name in for a wild card to nationals. That would seem to be a very outside shot at best and Windsor has to hope all goes according to plan in playoffs everywhere else in the country. Even that likely won’t be enough.
• Count me as one who is now pulling for a Brock-Carleton OUA final. The Badgers pushed the Ravens to the wire back in December. Yes, it was in St. Catharines, but the Badgers aren’t a team that seems to have any fear of facing up against big bad CU. Brock head coach Ken Murray, for the record, said most teams go in hesitant against the five-time defending champs and that’s where Carleton dominates you. Don’t expect the Badgers to be filled with trepidation. They’ve seen it before.
Western, however, is surging and might have the bigs to match up well with Carleton should the Mustangs get by Brock. We’re not forgetting Ottawa either, but I still don’t trust them. I’m going Carleton-Brock in the OUA final with the Ravens pulling out an eight-point win.

Two guys who love sports, almost more than women...
February 28th, 2008 at 5:16 pm
Well said on the Can West award, should have either of the other 3 coaches whose teams are in the CW Final Four… and you just can’t help but think conspiracy when Henry Bekkering isn’t first-team all-Canada West. That’s a head-scratcher after the stats he put up and all the attention he’s got.
It’s like when Sidney Crosby was in AAA midget in Nova Scotia and was left off the league’s first all-star team when he was the leading scorer in the league.
February 28th, 2008 at 7:14 pm
Being a Dino fan, I freely admit bias. But Brandon pulls one first team, one second team all star AND defensive player of the year? Where’s Ross Bekkering in the all stars, or do rebounds, blocks and ppg not count? And Coach Horwood? I’ve watched him 4 times this year. He doesn’t deserve it, coaching Andrew Parker to technical fouls…
U of C is more than Henry. This is the team that’s been 2nd to 4th ranked nationally, and that’s all the recognition they get? I suspect someone will be eating crow after this weekend.
February 28th, 2008 at 7:15 pm
Here is the link to CIS top ten rules-
http://www.cisport.ca/e/play_regs/documents/BBallM_000.pdf
Notice point iii below
D.2.2.2 SELECTION CRITERIA (GUIDELINES FOR THE TOP TEN)
i) All games versus Canadian Interuniversity Sport opponents will count. Games versus NCAA senior teams and community colleges will not count but the results of the competition should be recorded with the Canadian Interuniversity Sport Office and published.
ii) Teams that lose a game should not move up except if teams ranked above them have all lost and the head to head performance of the losing team is better than other teams in consideration.
iii) Best 2 out of 3 playoff series will count as one game when voting for top 10.
iv) There is no extrapolating of votes.
v) Location of game (home, away, and neutral) can be used as a criteria in weighting the significance of a win or loss.
vi) In Sport Conference playoffs, if a lower team defeats a higher team, the following guidelines would apply:
a. if teams are ranked 1 or 2 positions apart, they could flip flop positions
b. if the teams are ranked 3 or more positions apart and have been considered throughout the season, the lower team should move up and the higher team should drop but not necessarily below the team that defeated them.
Top Ten Rules
A. The previous week’s top ten is the starting point for the vote each week.
B. A team in the top ten may drop a maximum of three spots per loss.
C. No team may move down more than 2 spots if they have not played a game.
D. There will be only one top ten each week.
E. If a team is still in the top ten after losing a playoff game, they may not be moved out the following week. They are to be frozen or even possibly move up if a team above them loses.
F. Regional Top Ten representatives vote to determine the weekly ranking with input from coaches within their regions in additional to information such as RPI and power rankings.
February 28th, 2008 at 10:04 pm
you’re rigth Derek, UofC is more than Henry, which probably didn’t help when it came time to vote. Take him away and the Dinos would still be pretty good. That and he really didn’t have big games against the other final 4 teams during the regular season UBC - 5 pts, Brandon - 13, UofA - 28,10,13 & 15. As for Ross he missed the last 3 weeks of the season with an ankle inury so that might have affected him. Henry did pick it up when ROss was out at leasat in the games I saw. They should win this weekend aginst the Birds, can’t wait to see the crowd at the Jack! Should be even better than last weekend.Just win this weekend and who cares what everyone else says then.
I think Horwood won because his team probably wasn’t expected to do as well as last year before the season. I think most people had them behind the Dinos and the Huskies.They didn’t add anyone new but they had a great season, better than last year with basically the same team after losing Gordon and JOnes. I wouldn’t have thought that heading into this year. Even though I’m not a bears fan, it would be great to have 2 teams from the province at nationals.
March 1st, 2008 at 11:45 pm
Having just watched Brandon rout the Dinos, the night after the Dinos were stomped by UBC, the crow eaters are us. The way we played the last two nights, the Dinos were lucky to get Henry on the second team, and Mr. Fidler and his 0-10/0-6 performance — well, lets just say he succumbed to pressure.
I apologize. The coaches got it right.
And three cheers for Mr. Horwood. He methodically took down the Bobcats, and nearly did the same with UBC. A fine job for an unranked team coached very well.
Crow, by the way, doesn’t taste that good.